RCR Wireless
  • News
  • Channels
    • 5G
    • 6G
    • BSS OSS
    • Carriers
    • IoT
    • Network Infrastructure
    • Open RAN
    • Private 5G
    • Telco AI
    • Telco Cloud
    • Test & Measurement
  • Resources
    • Reports
    • Webinars
    • White papers
    • AI Fundamentals
    • Analyst Angle
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Fundamentals
      • 5G NR Release 17
      • AI
        • Telco AI in 2025
    • Podcasts
      • Let’s Get Digital with Carrie Charles
      • Wireless Connectivity to Enable Industry 4.0 for the Middleprise
      • Well Technically…
      • Will 5G Change the World
      • Accelerating Industry 4.0 Digitalization
  • AI Infrastructure
  • Programs
  • Events
  • RCRtv
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
Sunday, August 9, 2026
RCR Wireless
  • News
  • Channels
    • 5G
    • 6G
    • BSS OSS
    • Carriers
    • IoT
    • Network Infrastructure
    • Open RAN
    • Private 5G
    • Telco AI
    • Telco Cloud
    • Test & Measurement
  • Resources
    • Reports
    • Webinars
    • White papers
    • AI Fundamentals
    • Analyst Angle
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Fundamentals
      • 5G NR Release 17
      • AI
        • Telco AI in 2025
    • Podcasts
      • Let’s Get Digital with Carrie Charles
      • Wireless Connectivity to Enable Industry 4.0 for the Middleprise
      • Well Technically…
      • Will 5G Change the World
      • Accelerating Industry 4.0 Digitalization
  • AI Infrastructure
  • Programs
  • Events
  • RCRtv
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
Add RCR Wireless as a preferred source on Google
  • Qualcomm 6G Insights
  • Huawei Content Hub
  • Qualcomm – 6G Vision
  • OSS/BSS Channel
  • RCRTech Roundtable: AI Infrastructure
RCR Wireless
RCR Wireless
  • Advanced Mimo
  • Mobile mmWave
  • 5G Positioning
  • Green Networks
  • Metaverse
  • Automotive
  • Industrial and Wide-area IoT
Copyright 2021 - All Right Reserved
Home - NTP accuses six heavyweights in lawsuit over wireless e-mail patent
Wireless

NTP accuses six heavyweights in lawsuit over wireless e-mail patent

by Matt Kapko July 9, 2010
written by Matt Kapko July 9, 2010 Share
LinkedinEmail
Share 0LinkedinEmail
84

If there’s one thing NTP Inc. is really good at, it’s protecting patents with a fervor and winning handsome treasure along the way. Just ask BlackBerry-maker Research In Motion Ltd. (RIM).
After battling it out in court for the better part of five years over patents related to wireless e-mail delivery, RIM finally settled with NTP in 2006 for $612.5 million. As to be expected, RIM’s chairman Jim Balsillie began lobbying for patent reform immediately after the payout.
Since then, the Richmond, Va.-based company has attempted to bolster its patents and gone after Palm and all of the top tier U.S. carriers.
Today the company is at it again, this time going after the heavyweights in mobile devices. Apple Inc. (AAPL), Google Inc. (GOOG), HTC Corp. (HTCXF), LG Electronics Inc. (LGEAF), Microsoft Corp. (MSFT) and Motorola Inc. (MOT).
In a suit filed yesterday in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, NTP accuses all six companies of infringing on eight patents “related to the delivery of electronic mail over wireless communications systems.”
NTP mentioned its “long litigation and eventual settlement” with RIM in a press release about this most recent court filing. In late 2009, after the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office reexamined NTP’s patents, it ruled that 67 of the company’s patent claims in four patents are valid, according to the company. Other claims were rejected by the USPTO, but are on appeal.
The six companies caught in NTP’s legal cross hairs are surely taking notice today, considering the massive sum RIM paid for similar claims. And, Tom Campana, the company founder who claims to have invented wireless e-mail, and his lawyers could be seeing a lot more cash if the latest claims hold up in court.
In other patent litigation news, FlashPoint Technology Inc. has also filed a complaint with the U.S. International Trade Commission accusing four major device majors of infringement, according to Reuters. The trade panel has agreed to investigate whether Nokia Corp. (NOK), RIM, HTC and LG have infringed on four of the company’s patents related to “electronic imaging devices.”

You Might Also Like
  • Verizon’s Srini Kalapala on betting on AI and edge computing
  • T-Mobile bets on hybrid broadband with 5G FWA and Starlink
  • Emerson/NI White Paper: 2026 Technology Trends Impacting the Wireless Communications Industry
  • Wireless system testing enhances automotive connectivity
  • Telefônica, Nokia fast-track Petrobras private LTE rollout to 18 sites in Brazil
  • Boingo Wireless to deploy DAS network at Omni PGA Frisco Resort
Share 0 LinkedinEmail
Matt Kapko

Former Feature writer for RCR Wireless NewsCurrently writing for CIOhttp://www.CIO.com/ Matt Kapko specializes in the convergence of social media, mobility, digital marketing and technology. As a senior writer at CIO.com, Matt covers social media and enterprise collaboration. Matt is a former editor and reporter for ClickZ, RCR Wireless News, paidContent and mocoNews, iMedia Connection, Bay City News Service, the Half Moon Bay Review, and several other Web and print publications. Matt lives in a nearly century-old craftsman in Long Beach, Calif. He enjoys traveling and hitting the road with his wife, going to shows, rooting for the 49ers, gardening and reading.

previous post
Five failed mobile devices
next post
Ericsson jumps on M2M bandwagon

White Papers

  • Norton eBook: The 2026 Telco Playbook

  • Enea White Paper: Why Intelligent AAA is the Swiss Army Knife of Telecom

  • CSG White Paper: Telco AI Enabler: Mediation’s Defining Role

  • Enea White Paper: Scalable Database Design for 5G and Beyond

  • Supermicro and NVIDIA Whitepaper: Powering sovereign AI at scale

Editorial Reports

  • Report: NTN in motion — evolving standards, expanding services

  • Market Pulse Report: Telco AI in 2026 – Trends, Challenges and Opportunities

  • Nvidia Report: The State of AI in Telecommunications: 2026 Trends

Webinars

  • Webinar: Building 6G — aligning technology, policy and purpose

  • SIMCom Webinar: Scaling your next deployment – from plastic to provisioning

  • Webinar: Rethinking the RAN as AI, cloud and openness converge

  • Webinar: Scale-Up, Scale-Out, Scale-Across – Building AI-Era Network Fabrics

  • Webinar: NTN in motion – evolving standards, expanding services

Since 1982, RCR Wireless News has been providing wireless and mobile industry news, insights, and analysis to mobile and wireless industry professionals, decision makers, policy makers, analysts and investors.

Facebook Twitter Youtube Linkedin Envelope Rss

Useful Links

  • Subscribe
  • About RCR Wireless News
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Editorial Calendar
  • Archive
  • RSS
  • Wireless News Archive
  • Subscribe
  • About RCR Wireless News
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Editorial Calendar
  • Archive
  • RSS
  • Wireless News Archive

Edtior's Picks

The Agentic Network — NVIDIA on the full-stack path to telecom autonomy
Ericsson named sole global tech partner in SK Telecom-led AI-RAN pilot
Bell advances AIDC strategy as fiber and enterprise AI drive Q2

Latest Articles

The Agentic Network — NVIDIA on the full-stack path to telecom autonomy
Ericsson named sole global tech partner in SK Telecom-led AI-RAN pilot
Bell advances AIDC strategy as fiber and enterprise AI drive Q2
Context before control – Blue Planet maps AI architecture for autonomous networks

© 2026 RCR Wireless News All Right Reserved. Developed by Eight Hats.

Cookie Policy | Privacy Policy

RCR Wireless
  • News
  • Channels
    • 5G
    • 6G
    • BSS OSS
    • Carriers
    • IoT
    • Network Infrastructure
    • Open RAN
    • Private 5G
    • Telco AI
    • Telco Cloud
    • Test & Measurement
  • Resources
    • Reports
    • Webinars
    • White papers
    • AI Fundamentals
    • Analyst Angle
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Fundamentals
      • 5G NR Release 17
      • AI
        • Telco AI in 2025
    • Podcasts
      • Let’s Get Digital with Carrie Charles
      • Wireless Connectivity to Enable Industry 4.0 for the Middleprise
      • Well Technically…
      • Will 5G Change the World
      • Accelerating Industry 4.0 Digitalization
  • AI Infrastructure
  • Programs
  • Events
  • RCRtv
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
RCR Wireless
  • News
  • Channels
    • 5G
    • 6G
    • BSS OSS
    • Carriers
    • IoT
    • Network Infrastructure
    • Open RAN
    • Private 5G
    • Telco AI
    • Telco Cloud
    • Test & Measurement
  • Resources
    • Reports
    • Webinars
    • White papers
    • AI Fundamentals
    • Analyst Angle
    • Editorial Calendar
    • Fundamentals
      • 5G NR Release 17
      • AI
        • Telco AI in 2025
    • Podcasts
      • Let’s Get Digital with Carrie Charles
      • Wireless Connectivity to Enable Industry 4.0 for the Middleprise
      • Well Technically…
      • Will 5G Change the World
      • Accelerating Industry 4.0 Digitalization
  • AI Infrastructure
  • Programs
  • Events
  • RCRtv
  • Advertise
  • Subscribe
@2020 - All Right Reserved. Designed and Developed by PenciDesign